Knowledge Management Models
Introduction
The purpose of this article is to present in depth analysis of one of the knowledge Management Models i.e. Nonaka’s “SECI”. This piece of writing is composed of four sections. In the first section I’ll be giving overview of the topic by describing the Model. In the second section I’ll be conducting critical analysis of the model; this includes few critiques on the model by experts as well as my own position in that context. Third section consists of discussion about my own organization which in this case is the class of knowledge management (BIS 4410) and explanation about how Nonaka’s model relates to my organization. In the fourth and last section I’ll reveal what I have learned about this topic from my group and other class members.
1.1 Overview of Nonaka’s Model
Ikujurio Nonaka, a professor at Hitotusbashi University and the University of California at Berkeley(Nonaka 1991; Nonaka et. al. 1994; Nonaka & Takeuchi 1995; Nonaka & konno 1998; Nonaka et. al. 2000; 2001a; Nonaka & Toyama 2003), articulated a model of “knowledge creation” in a series of articles and books dating from the early 1990s. The SECI (Socialization, Externalization, Combination, and Internalization) model first appeared in 1991 and attained recognition as a useful and rigorous approach to describing the ways knowledge is generated, transferred and re-created in organizations. In brief, the model incorporates the following:
- Two forms of Knowledge (tacit and explicit)
- An Interaction Dynamic (transfer)
- Three levels of social aggregation (individual, group, context)
- Four “knowledge-creating” processes socialization,externalization,
combination and internalization)
The interaction between tacit knowledge (non-verbalized, intuitive and unarticulated) and explicit knowledge (being in writing, drawings) is known as “Knowledge Conversion”
The model proposes that a “knowledge creating company” consciously facilitates the interplay of tacit and explicit forms of knowledge this is accomplished through systems and structures and a corporate culture, which facilitates the interaction of four knowledge creating processes, per the following
1. Socialization (From Tacit to Tacit): Usually it happens as a result of two way communication between individuals, in which one person shifts his/her tacit knowledge acquired through past experiences or learning to other person (Geytere T, 2007). This is done through joint activities and physical proximity
2. Externalization (From tacit to explicit): This phase guarantees that the knowledge is available to others even after the person who acquired tacit knowledge is unavailable. Basically it addresses to the safety of tacit knowledge. (Geytere T, 2007).The expression of tacit knowledge in publicly comprehensible forms.
3. Combination (From explicit to explicit): Explicit knowledge is transformed to more complex forms of explicit knowledge (Geytere T, 2007). It refers to communication, dissemination systemization of explicit knowledge
4. Internalization (From explicit to tacit): Explicit knowledge is transformed to tacit knowledge (Geytere T, 2007). The embodiment of explicit knowledge into actions, practices, processes and strategic initiatives
Critical for Nonaka is the interaction dynamic between forms of knowledge and levels of organization. He proposes that the spiral resulting from the exchange of tacit and explicit knowledge across different organizational levels is the key to knowledge creation and re-creation. The prescription is that companies should recognize the importance of this interaction dynamic and imbed the mechanisms that make it possible. In 1998 Nonaka and Konno introduced the concept of Ba which relates to the English concept of place.A Ba in knowledge management is a space for dynamic knowledge conversion and emerging relationships. Four Ba’s are defined by Nonaka (1998)
- Originating Ba: a space where individuals share feelings, emotions, experiences and mental models
- Interacting Ba: A place where tacit knowledge is made explicit. Two key factors are dialogue and metaphors
- Cyber Ba: A space of interaction in a virtual world. Implicates the combination of new and existing explicit knowledge throughout the organization
- Exercising Ba: a space that facilitates the conversion of explicit knowledge into tacit
Ba calls attention to the fact that knowledge is context-dependent: it cannot be separated from its "place" in any meaningful way. Each knowledge-creating process therefore requires a Ba, a phenomenal space whose importance should be recognized by the organization. The organization, in fact, should focus significant attention on the development of its Bas since more is to be gained by developing the environment around knowledge processes than efforts directed at the processes themselves.
1.2 Critical Analysis of “SECI Model”
Although Nonaka’s model of knowledge creation is one of the widely accepted models within the society, it has also faced a lot of criticism from experts from various parts of the world ranging from the concept itself to its implementation.
I’ve chosen two critiques from the literature and supported one of them with an example
Critique 1: Criticizing on the fact that “SECI” model only takes tacit and explicit forms of knowledge into account, McLoughlin & Thorpe articulates that “is it appropriate to solely categorise knowledge in such a way?” Where does the concept of P and Q knowledge (McLoughlin and Thorpe, 1993) fit with this view, where P is programmed knowledge and Q is knowledge gained by questioning insight. Tacit knowledge does not exactly map onto Q, neither does explicit knowledge exactly map onto P. Thus P and Q represent a different categorization of knowledge. Therefore from a critical standpoint Nonaka's categorization of knowledge is perhaps limited or uni-dimensional.
Critique 2: Doyle (1985) and Glisby and Holden (2003) argue that the model rests on Japanese mangement cultural practices, and is thus not transfrable to other environments
Support: In Pakistan the autocratic or authoritative management style is practiced in majority of organizations, where managers like to make all the important decisions and closely supervise and control workers. Managers simply give orders (one-way communication) that they expect to be obeyed and employees work somewhat efficiently under this system.
On the other side, democratic style of management is common in majority of American organizations, where managers give more power to employees by putting faith in them and encouraging them to make decisions. Therefore democratic style of management simply cannot be implemented in Pakistani organizations due to its incompatibility with the workforce. Mapping the above criticism on this explanation, reveals that a well operating system in one country is totally impractical in the other. Nonaka’s model suffers from the same dilemma as it only considers Japanese management culture which restricts its worldwide practicality.
1.3 Reflections on Practice
How “SECI” (Socialization, Externalization Combination and Internalization) took place in my organization (Class of BIS 4410). My organization can be well classified in all the four of the Ba’s such as originating Ba, interacting Ba, Cyber Ba and Exercising Ba.
Socialization: The students of BIS4410 were combined as four different groups. The members of these groups started communicating with each other to come up with a mutual consensus on the weekly themes assigned by managers (Aboubakr M and M Woodman). The two way communication occurred through group activities such as brain storming and discussion sessions within the group members. Each member of the group shared his/her tacit knowledge about the topic in question. In doing so, each of them was imparting his/her tacit knowledge to other member.
Externalization: Knowledge Management was something relatively new for all the students; and so were the weekly themes (tacit knowledge). The members combined their tacit knowledge with explicit knowledge available in the literature and resultantly came up with more concrete knowledge that was not only understandable to them but also by other groups (explicit knowledge).
Combination: Combination took place when the groups performed as a team by combining all the resources such as ideas, views, knowledge and work in order to overcome an issue. It is worth noticing that so far in every step of the way, knowledge is constantly being refined.
Internalization: From the very first day of the beginning of my organization our managers made us clear that this organization is all about learning by doing. Therefore BIS 4410 was a learning organization to begin with. Each group member was initially supposed to come up with his/her own position and later on with a more explicit view of the topic through research and inquiry. Members also learned to create and manage blogs as well as problem solving technique through discussions and presentations. By undertaking each and every task the members were not only learning by doing but also internalizing each and every aspect of learning.
1.4 Learning from Others
Following are few well informing points in Samir Shaikh’s blog that enhanced my learning regarding the limitations of Nonaka’s “SECI” Model:
Learning Outcome 1
The model only addresses Japanese organizations and employees where the rate of switching jobs is very low and people stick to one job for the lifetime. What about the countries with high rate in attrition. This point somehow validates the critique I made in section 1.2 (Critique 2)
Learning Outcome 2
Samir also talked about Knowledge possessiveness in terms of people acquiring knowledge by putting time and effort. I support this point because one might feel uncomfortable sharing it with others especially when we talk about upward mobility in organizations
References
1. Doyle, J. L. (1985). Commentary: Managing the new product development process: How Japanese companies learn and unlearn. In K. B. Clark, R. H. Hayes, & C. Lorenz (Eds.), The uneasy alliance: Managing the productivity-technology
dilemma (pp. 377–381). Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Retrieved March 11, 2008, from http://www.emeraldinsight.com/
2. McAdam, R and S. McCreedy (1999a) “A Critical Review of Knowledge Management Models”, The Learning Organization, 6(3), p.91. March 11, 2008, from http://www.emeraldinsight.com/
3. Nonaka, I., & Takeuchi, H. (1995). The knowledge-creating company. New York:
Oxford University Press. Retrieved March 11, 2008, from http://www.12manage.com/methods_nonaka_seci.html
4. Perez. P (2002)
Retrieved March 11, 2008,
from http://www.knowledgeboard.com/item/380/23/5/3
5. Shaikh S (Middlesex University, 2008)
6. Tom De Geytere (2007), "Unified model of dynamic organisational knowledge creation"
Retrieved March 11, 2008
from http://www.12manage.com/methods_nonaka_seci.html
.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment